Chapter 1 - The Bassinet That Sat EmptyEight years ago, I went into labor far too early with twin boys. When I finally woke two days later, there was exactly one bassinet sitting beside my bed, and exactly one sleeping baby inside it.
I turned my head slowly and whispered, "Where's the other baby?"
Gareth lowered his eyes. "He didn't make it."
I never saw a body. I never once attended a funeral. Gareth told me he'd handled absolutely everything while I lay unconscious. I believed him completely, purely because I had no remaining strength left for anything else that day.
After that, I poured every ounce of my love straight into Jasper instead. He was loud, funny, thoroughly stubborn, and I told myself grief simply had an afterlife somewhere, and this happened to be mine.
Gareth changed noticeably after the birth. He grew quieter, considerably more careful about exactly what he told me. Whenever I asked about the funeral itself, he said he simply couldn't bear describing it a second time. I mistook his growing distance for grief, purely because I had no idea it was actually guilt underneath.
By the time Jasper started elementary school, our life together looked steady once again. Then one evening he came home, threw his backpack hard onto the floor, and snapped, "Milo called me his brother again."
I very nearly smiled at that. "Maybe he's simply teasing you."
Jasper glared at me. "He keeps saying we have the same dad but different moms. It's so genuinely annoying."
For one second, my stomach tightened involuntarily. Then I told myself kids simply said strange things sometimes. I told Jasper to ignore him entirely. He stormed upstairs, and I did my best to forget the whole exchange.
A week later, the principal called. "Jasper got into another fight with Milo. You need to come in immediately."
By the time I reached the school, I was already mentally preparing to apologize for my son's temper. I rushed into the office, saw Jasper sitting there with a split lip, and asked immediately, "Are you okay?"
He pointed silently behind me.
Another boy sat over by the filing cabinet. He had the exact same gray eyes, the same narrow chin, the same small birthmark near his eyebrow. Jasper's hair sat lighter in color, but otherwise the two of them looked like a single child somehow split cleanly in two.
The principal told me Milo had tried sitting beside Jasper at lunch that day. Jasper told him plainly to go away. Milo said, "You can be mad, but I'm still your brother." Jasper hit him. Milo hit back. They both ended up crying, which somehow made the whole thing feel considerably worse.
"How is this even possible?" I whispered, staring at the two boys.
The principal folded her hands calmly on the desk. "We're waiting for the other parent, and then you'll finally understand everything."
The door opened right then. I turned and saw my own younger sister, Carrie, standing in the doorway.
"Mom."
I hadn't actually spoken to Carrie since the weeks immediately following Jasper's birth. Gareth had told me she'd stopped answering my calls, because she genuinely couldn't bear being near my baby after learning she couldn't have children of her own. I'd written her emails that bounced straight back. Left voicemails she never once returned. Gareth held me while I cried and said quietly, "Some people simply leave when pain gets too close to them."
May you like
Carrie asked the principal to send both boys back to class so the adults present could actually talk properly. Once the door finally closed behind them, she looked directly at me and asked, "Did Gareth genuinely never tell you?"
I laughed once, sharp. "Tell me what, exactly?"
